FORESHADOWING

Saturday, February 24, 2007

I have not blogged in awhile! For shame on me. In my defense, I have had house guests most of the month (all of the kids' grandparents) and have faced a work tsunami. So you'll get a bunch of posts in the coming days.

For now I want to talk about the grade school Variety Show that Sarah participated in last week.

In general, you have to hand it to these kids for getting up in front of all their peers and a packed auditorium of other viewers and displaying their talents. There were some kids with voices cracking, but no no-shows, stage fright, or puking! Quite impressive!

Sarah did great. She played her piece on the piano beautifully. She didn't really do the bowing part a great service, but the talent part was very sweet and enjoyable. And takes a lot of guts in my book.

I have to say, sitting in the audience, you do get an idea of what will happen in the future for these kids.

The kids who get up and lip sync to Brittney Spears songs, are peaking in 6th grade, to steal a phrase from my friend Allison. They're the popular girls, the cheerleaders, then the sorority girls, who become Consumers. They will follow the crowd and do what is obviously vetted as "cool," their whole lives. Apple loves them.

The kids who made up their own jumproping hip hop routines, will set those trends. They are the early adopters, the risk-takers. Next stop: graffiti art.

The kindergartner who stole the show with a breakdancing routine: future broadcaster. The only kid with a magnetism that I still recall, days later. That's a rare gift.

And the kid who delivered a recitation of the Jabberwocky even though he had a slight speech impediment? That guy's going into advertising. He's going to have to come to terms with being different, and that he has tastes his peers don't understand. It will make him pensive and visionary. In fact, I think I have an internship opening for him.

And what about kids like Sarah, who play instruments or take dance lessons or gymnastics class? You know what? I think we're a bit on the conformist side. We measure our progress against classical norms. I'm not meaning to take anything away from them. But as parents, I think what we're teaching them is that their talents come down to a series of expected judgments. Did you hit all the notes? get the timing right? play expressively? then you did it and you get our approval! This is what they get all day long in school, too. So are we sentencing these kids to live conformist lives, and quelling their creativity?

It's the girl that sat down and played a piece she wrote herself, that made me really think. And remind myself that we must also foster free thinking if we want our kids to realize their potential.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't agree that having your kids take those "typical" classes like music, dance, gymnastics, etc. dooms them to a life of "conformity" (there are worse things!) or quells creativity. While it is true that kids in those classes are expected to perform in a certain way, they are learning more important life skills that will get them farther than learning a certain piece or routine ever will - how to interact with teachers and peers, exploring different learning modalities that aren't tapped into in regular classroom settings, group/teamwork, good sportsmanship, taking personal responsibility... I could go on and on. (Spoken like a true teacher, eh?)
I don't think any creativity is stifled at all - think about how many times you tried to play a song from the radio by ear on the piano, or drew a funny cartoon for your sister at camp, or wrote a song or poem parody for your siblings' bar and bat mitzvahs and weddings. YOU took piano and dance and sang in the choir... and your job is completely creativity-based, and you are also one of the most creative-minded people I know, n'est-ce pas?!

Michelle Edelman said...

Good points, good points. In my case, though, I also had a natural penchant for rule-breaking (recall the 6th grade door incident?)...

Anonymous said...

Yes, you should NOT have used the six grade door! But that isn't a result of rebelling against piano lessons (was it?)

Anonymous said...

Oh, how I love when my children interact! So, now the question is, does 70- year old Lou Kram sleep in the same bedroom as his lady friend or what?

Anonymous said...

Then again, your only piano teacher murdered her husband... so I don't know where that leaves you.

Michelle Edelman said...

Yes, Lou Kram can sleep in the same bedroom as his lady friend. There are no impressionable youngsters in your house, and he shouldn't have to save himself for marriage.